.comment-link {margin-left:.6em;}

Sight Screen

Sunday, October 02, 2005

Sunday roundup (-worma)

World XI made a winning start against Victoria...and guess who were the key performers for them! Dravid made a typical anchoring 66(70b) when the WXI were wobbling in mid innings...with Gayle(batting at 8!) and Pollock providing the partnership. Shoaib and Murali then had good spells with the ball.

But the match turned out to be close..since Victoria also had some quality players, close on national fringes...and Hodge and White made it count. Harwood was their best bowler(dunno much about him).


Back to Indian news...and Sachin, who had earlier stated that there was still some pain in the elbow, has now confirmed further that his foray into the middle is just at the right time, and after the requisite expert consultations.
I am doing this after consulting the doctor who performed the corrective surgery in England. We decided that this is the right time to at least go and have a hit
And he has also been repeating that this, afterall, is his way of judging the status of the elbow and the whole situation...and not an outright confirmation of his return to international scene.
I would exactly know where I stand and basically that becomes my target. After the Challenger, I will be in a better position to figure out how it (left elbow) is


Kiran More, does say here that some of the names missing in the Challenger squad were still in contention and age has not been the criteria for ruling out players.

Which brings back the Kumble question, as I said yesterday. Now there is one report which does mention him being under rehab for four weeks...although no specific reasons mentioned.

Some more positive news....as mentioned in the review committee report (yes 'that' review committee)...there was discussion on doing away with the zonal selection system. Given the immense importance of this issue, it was surprising how little it was talked about in the media.... and even here. But this report again mentions(if you ignore the heading) that there are enough indications of the change being considered seriously. Maybe as soon as the next AGM (yes the postponed one).

I guess if the election issue is settled beforehand, then there are chances of this being brought up. Meanwhile...here is one reason why a delay of a couple of months on such a big change won't make too much of a difference(as long as it does come later)
A senior Indian cricketer told The Indian Express: "The current 16 players in the Indian team are the best available. So there is no need to change things for the time being."


Here is an interview with Sandeep Patil, touching on this issue among others. Also mentions this important bit
I would also be happy if the BCCI appoints a permanent manager. South Africa has had Ghoolam Rajah for several years and Australia has Steve Bernard and both have produced results. Continuity has to be maintained to avoid anomalies creeping into reports submitted by different managers


Meanwhile, read here(towards the end of the article) what Ian Frazer has to say about the fitness schedule of our team. Also...this bit was important
He also had another significant observation: seniors aren'’t passing on enough tips to the youngsters. "‘I'’d like to see the Sachins talk a lot more to the young boys, try and tell them about their experiences and how they handled a particular situation."’
Ofcourse he didn't actually mean Sachin, since he(and GC) haven't yet worked with him...but still this comes as a surprise to me.

13 Comments:

  • worma / all,

    one more noteworthy story for the round up here : Murali Kartik the batsman seeking to catch selectors' eyes in light of Harbhajan "Big Mouth" Singh's travails:)

    By Blogger dna, at 08:55  

  • @all,
    i think the performances of the likes of karthik, powar and parida will be interesting ... with harbhajan in mediocre form (at least as far as ODIs are concerned) ... there cud be a vacancy for the spinner sometime in the season

    By Blogger Gaurav, at 09:35  

  • yes I think we may see some new ODI spin/allround prospects coming up in this season...from Irani....Challenger etc..not necessarily as a replacement for bhajji..but still

    By Blogger worma, at 09:43  

  • idlivada, IMO the purpose of the Challenger is not to give the seniors a good workout..which used to happen earlier..now they would be facing a real match situation with non of their everyday colleagues on the other side....and more importantly the newcomers...the ones who really need to be tested in best possible domestic condition to know how good they are before thrusting them onto international scene....would be playing a game against a near top quality opposition in the seniors...probably the best way to know how e.g. a piyush chawla would fare against an international batting lineup...get him to bowl at Indian top order...etc

    ..regarding the winner...am not so sure....there can be a few surprises....ODI games is so much about playing good on a single day....and nothing more.....and on that day a b'desh can surprise an Aus side...

    that cross-generational thing that frazer mentioned is for the newcomers in the actual Indian team....let some of these yougsters qualify for that first...and anyway in a 4-5 day competition you dont expect them to sit with the Indian international players for a tution lesson for tips....happens over a period of time...when they have long term working relationship...

    By Blogger worma, at 12:18  

  • http://www.hindu.com/2005/10/02/stories/2005100203271900.htm

    Patil glad his reports were kept confidential

    G. Viswanath

    Anything written about the captain becomes a national story, says the former India coach

    # Patil has reported on captains of three countries
    # Recommended replacement of Azharuddin in 1996
    # Suggested Tikolo take over from Odumbe for World Cup 2007



    Sandeep Patil

    Mumbai: Sandeep Patil, former India coach, expressing surprise at Greg Chappell's confidential report to the BCCI on Sourav Ganguly being leaked to the media, said he was happy that his report on the captain of the Indian team for the 1996 tour of England is still classified information.

    Patil, who was India `A' coach ten years ago, was on Thursday named coach of India `A' for the Challenger Series.

    He was coach of the national team for five months and on tours to Singapore, Sharjah, England, Sri Lanka and Toronto. Mohammad Azharuddin was the Indian captain on the English tour in 1996.

    Speaking to The Hindu on Saturday, Patil said: "Chappell's report on Ganguly is not the first instance of a coach making observations about the captain. I have reported on captains of three countries. First it was the Indian captain after returning from England, then Kenya and more recently Oman.

    "In 1996, not only was the Indian captain (Azharuddin) removed, but I was also removed after the tour of Toronto (Sahara Cup). I had explained the reasons and convinced the BCCI president I.S. Bindra and secretary Jagmohan Dalmiya to change the captain and had discussed the matter with the national selectors at Eden Gardens.

    Thereafter it has been their decision. Fortunately, all this has not been leaked to the media.''

    In 2003, Patil was the coach of the Kenya team for the World Cup in South Africa.

    "I recommended to the Kenyan Cricket Board that it should replace Maurice Odumbe with Steve Tikolo as captain for the World Cup.

    Then recently, the Oman Cricket Board, on my recommendation, replaced the long-standing captain Ali Akbar with Azar Ali. But all the reports and discussions have not been leaked. I'm very happy about it. I'm surprised Chappell's report on Ganguly has been leaked. Anything written about the captain becomes a national story,'' said Patil.

    A positive step

    Patil supported the Review Committee's recommendation to the BCCI's Working Committee to discard the `one-from-each-zone' system for choosing national selectors.

    "It's an excellent idea and a positive step because for quality selection, you need quality selectors. With due respect to all past and present selectors who have done a fine job, I think the fresh proposal will only help the system. Karnataka has already taken the initiative.

    "I would also be happy if the BCCI appoints a permanent manager. South Africa has had Ghoolam Rajah for several years and Australia has Steve Bernard and both have produced results. Continuity has to be maintained to avoid anomalies creeping into reports submitted by different managers.''

    Accepts invitation

    Patil has accepted BCCI's invitation to be the coach of the India `A' team for the Challenger Series and wants to clear a misunderstanding. "I had informed both Mr. Ranbir Singh and Mr. S.K. Nair that I am available to serve Indian cricket at any level, provided I am told in advance, because I have commitments with the Complan Academy and also with Oman.

    "The BCCI has given me good time to prepare for the Challenger Series. Benefits from India `A' tours have been great over the last ten years and I would request BCCI to schedule a programme for the India `A' team, which has been a regular feeder line for the national team.

    "Chappell has been my idol since I was a schoolboy and I would like to continue in the same manner as I did when John Wright was in-charge.''

    Reacting to the proposal for a two-captain concept, Patil said: "The 12 one-day internationals against Sri Lanka and South Africa will be very important and provide an opportunity for the BCCI, coach and selectors to identify the captain for the 2007 World Cup. Thereafter India will be playing Pakistan and England, but it will be too late to make a change.

    The experiments may have failed in Sri Lanka and Zimbabwe, but India has the advantage of playing at home now and the selectors and coach will have the leverage to bring in fresh ideas.''

    By Blogger Kiran R, at 13:47  

  • idlivada, sure I am all for good interaction between seniors and freshers...and I believe most of our seniors are well into it (thats why i said I was surprised to read this coming from Frazer)...just meant to say that its probably not a good idea to design the Challenger tournament just to suit this need.

    By Blogger worma, at 13:56  

  • This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    By Blogger Raju, at 18:56  

  • This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    By Blogger Raju, at 18:57  

  • For my view on the teams selected for the ICC XI, please visit here

    By Blogger Raju, at 19:03  

  • probably tensports, thechowmeinwarrior.

    i checked the schedule and they only have 2 hr highlights scheduled now. quite sure they'll show it though.

    otherwise just subscribe to set max.

    By Blogger Dhruv Deepak, at 22:49  

  • Deepak,

    Karthik bowled really well in the few county games he played (getting 10 wickets in one of them).

    I also saw him bowl (very well) in the last limited overs game against Wostershire.

    By Blogger Saurabh Wahi, at 05:52  

  • thechowmein.... you know what, you're right. SET max isnt there in the UAE, only Sony is.
    Better hope Tensports connects to it live, or FOX sports shows it (they showed the Ashes I believe, if that helps any)!

    oooh, this is what I found on Khaleej Times:

    “Channel 9 Australia will be the host broadcaster for the series and provide a world feed service to Sony Entertainment Television (SET) in Asia and the Middle East, BSkyB in the UK, Super Sport in Africa, the Caribbean Media Corporation in the Caribbean, Sky New Zealand and Echostar in North America,” an ICC statement said.

    Maybe Sony will switch from its original programming

    By Blogger Dhruv Deepak, at 05:55  

  • Hi ChowmeinWarrior,

    heard that the games are on willow.tv for US$ 39.00

    And out of curiosity, how do you fight? With Chopsticks?

    By Blogger Saurabh Wahi, at 07:53  

Post a Comment

<< Home