.comment-link {margin-left:.6em;}

Sight Screen

Monday, September 26, 2005

Today's story (by worma)

Here is what Sanjay Manjreker has to say on 'the issue'...this portion is the theme of his opinion
For me, this difficult choice that they have to make, is not so much between two people as it is between two ways to go ahead in Indian cricket.


..but before choosing, those in the say must also heed to this:
Coming back to the current issue, before the decision is made, the BCCI will surely talk to Chappell and Ganguly and if after that, they feel they need to go the Chappell way, it’s important they also find out whether the rest of the team and not only the new captain is ready to go the Chappell way.

For, you are talking of those players who found much of their success the Ganguly way.


Peter Roebuck also has a look at the controversy, and has advice for sides.

Meanwhile, there's even a leak of the questions that the committee is supposedly going to put up to GC and SG!

This story, in HT, gives a list of names supposedly on 'one side' and this one carries Bhajji's explanation on what he 'actually' meant, while giving statement in support of SG(and supposedly against GC)

Meanwhile, news doing the rounds that the dices are getting loaded in favour of SG, for the review meeting. Calling up the tour manager, who has already started giving statements refuting GC's claims, is one of them. Ahh...looks like big mess-up coming up.


A personal note, there would be a week-long blogging hiatus from my side...am on 'vacation' as they say here (yes in my part of the world they do have it!). Anyways...will keep a close eye on the 'news' around the showdown....and may the 'best' side win :-)

update : Do read this piece from Rahul Bhattacharya on the current situation. So far, probably the most balanced analysis of all the issues.

8 Comments:

  • WOW....great article by Rahul....no wonder he is amongst the best of cricinfo men!!....Most balanced views on this issue that I have seen so far.

    By Blogger worma, at 09:32  

  • What is Ganguly's performance as a captain in test matches?

    Check this on my blog-site:
    http://myhistoryisinteresting.blogspot.com/2005/09/analysing-gangulys-performance-in-test.html

    By Blogger Madhu Rao, at 09:58  

  • cricktip...you say loose loose only if GC turns out to be a wrong choice...otherwise SG going and GC retained is a win scenario..right??

    ...and if GC turns out a wrong choice later (take a mix of Rahul and Manjreker's views...thats what we should do now)..then obviously Indian cricket will have to pay a price for making a wrong choice...

    By Blogger worma, at 10:03  

  • worma,
    Enjoy your vacation :). Dont think you'll miss a lot by way of repair work on these issues from the BCCI's side.

    By Blogger Toney, at 10:21  

  • Rahul Battacharyas piece is the probably the most balanced analysis of this mess.

    I like it because for the first time some one in the media actually took the pains to analyze Chappells record as a coach.

    Mind you not his record as a captain or player but as a coach. From media reports from the time he was considered that was one thing completely missing.

    Everyone assured us that he was a legend and a Aussie so we cannot go wrong. No one really told us what his record as a coach was.

    By the way I am not a Ganguly supporter and I think he should be dropped but I certainly dont like the lynch mob that is gathering around him to hang him without hearing him out.

    By Blogger Hari, at 10:37  

  • Checking the latest Rediff team rankings India is ranked 4th in tests and 8th in ODIs (ICC rankings tests:3 and ODI:7). Yeah ... this team is top of the world, why do we need new thinking about playing the game. We wanted to be mediocre and we achieved it!

    By Blogger Gopal Bhagavatula, at 11:02  

  • Can anyone give pure cricketing reasons based on which Ganguly deserves a place in the team, as a player or captain?

    By Blogger Unknown, at 11:10  

  • dementor:

    *LOL*

    By Blogger Unknown, at 11:14  

Post a Comment

<< Home